Personal Injury Newsletter

Consolidating Similar Claims in a Class Action

A “class action” is a lawsuit brought by a representative plaintiff on behalf of a class of persons with similar claims. The class and the lawsuit must be certified by a judge as appropriate for class action treatment. If the case is certified, the lawsuit may proceed to resolve issues common to all class members. In general, notice of the lawsuit is mailed to all potential class members and, unless they “opt out,” all who fit within the class definition are automatically part of the lawsuit.

Situations where class action treatment is typical and may be appropriate include:

A mass accident – usually a single event such as an airplane crash
Widespread personal injuries from defective products – e.g., tires or pharmaceuticals
Where action or refusal to comply with laws affects a group of people – e.g., racial discrimination / civil rights action

Requirements for Class Actions

Generally, in federal or state court, a single plaintiff may sue on behalf of a class if all of the following are met:

A definable class exists, that can be certified
The plaintiffs are members of this class
The class is so numerous that trying each case individually would be impractical
The class members’ claims have common issues of law and fact
The representative plaintiff’s claims and defenses are typical of the class
The representative plaintiff will ensure fair and adequate representation of the interests of the members of the class

Advantages of Class Action Litigation

A class action may provide the only means of judicial relief for individuals, especially for small claims involving complex issues that would be expensive to litigate
The benefits from a strengthened negotiating position
Generally there is no payment or risk of legal fees – if the class wins, the lawyer gets a contingency fee; if the class loses, the lawyer generally gets nothing
There is a tolling or suspension of the limitation periods during the lawsuit for asserted class members who have not opted out to file an individual lawsuit
It may serve to consolidate numerous court actions into one, thereby relieving the burden on courts and avoiding inconsistent judgments
Litigation costs can be lowered by aggregating small claims
It can attract superior legal talent to represent the representative plaintiff

Disadvantages of Class Action Litigation

Resolution of class actions generally take much longer than conventional lawsuits due to their procedural complexities
They must be resolved in a common manner such that differences between individual cases are typically not emphasized
Individuals who participate typically give up their right to file suit individually
Class members generally play a lesser role in directing the litigation
Even if successful, participating members of the class may only be compensated with a minimal recovery

Driver's Duty to Passengers
If you are injured in a traffic collision while riding as a passenger in a vehicle, you may want to know about the driver’s liability toward you. The driver does have a duty to act responsibly toward you, but the extent of that duty... Read more.
Spousal Rights Regarding Personal Injury Awards
Upon termination of a marriage by divorce, one of the most difficult problems is often division of the couple’s real and personal property. Although there are considerable differences in the way states treat property acquired by... Read more.
Slip and Fall Injuries
There is no concise formula to determine whether injuries sustained from a fall are the responsibility of another. Each case is individually evaluated to see if the business or property owner was careful to prevent any injuries. The... Read more.
Tax Treatment of Personal Injury Awards
The U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) takes a broad view of what is considered “income” for purposes of taxation. The U.S. Supreme Court has provided additional interpretation, stating that “any funds” received by a taxpayer... Read more.

Law Commentary Legal News